A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF “MANHAJ”-TYPE WORKS ON HADITH METHODOLOGY WRITTEN IN THE 20TH CENTURY
Keywords:
Nur al-Din 'Itr, “Manhaj al-naqd”, hadith studies, comparative analysis, sanad and matn, methodology, mustalah al-hadith.Abstract
This article provides a comparative analysis of the specific features of Dr. Nur al-Din 'Itr's work “Manhaj al-naqd fi 'ulum al-hadith” with other contemporary and classical works written in the discipline of “Manhaj fi 'ulum al-hadith.” The main objective of the article is to reveal Nur al-Din 'Itr's unique methodology in classifying the sciences of hadith, particularly his epistemological shift in consolidating the scattered 65 categories from classical works into 6 major fundamental sections (narrators, transmission, sanad, matn, acceptance/rejection, and joint sciences). Furthermore, the study justifies why the author prioritized certain topics (e.g., the science of narrators and transmission) and how he seamlessly integrated the criticism of sanad and matn, by comparing his structural framework with the tables of contents of books by other authors such as Sharaf al-Qudat, Muhammad Samahi, and Ali Nayif Buqai.
References
Quzot Sh. Al-Manhaj al-hadis fi ulum al-hadis. – Amman: Dor al-furqon ,1999.
Buqoiy A.N. Al-Manhaj al-hadis fi tas’hiyl ulum al-hadis. – Bayrut: Dor al-bashair al-islamiya, 2002.
Itr N. Manhaj al-naqd fi ulum al-hadis. – Damashq: Dor al-fikr, 1997.
Jurakulov S. Nuriddin Itrning “Manhaj al-naqd fi ulum al-hadis” asari hadisshunoslikdagi muhim manba (Magistrlik dissertatsiyasi). – Toshkent: O‘zbekiston xalqaro islom akademiyasi, 2026.
Kiraz A., Alkasmalhadad A. A Study on The Book of Nureddin 'Itr and Manhaj an-Naqd fī 'ulūm al-Ḥadīth. – Gifad: Gümüşhane Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi, 2023. – 12(23). – S. 312-329.
Kurdian I.R., Pramesta B. va boshq. (2026). The Epistemological Shift in Hadith Science: From al-Hakim’s Systematic Classification to Nur al-Din ‘Itr’s Methodological Framework. – Diroyah: Jurnal Studi Ilmu Hadis, 10(2), 192.
Samohiy M. Al-Manhaj al-hadis fi ulum al-hadis (Mustalah al-hadis qismi va Roviylar qismi). – Qohira : nashriyoti berilmagan, 2000.
Quzot Sh. Al-Manhaj al-hadis fi ulum al-hadis. – Amman: Dor al-furqon ,1999.
Buqoiy. A.N. Al-Manhaj al-hadis fi tas’hiyl ulum al-hadis. – Bayrut: Dor al-bashair al-islamiya, 2002.
Itr. N. Manhaj al-naqd fi ulum al-hadis. – Damashq: Dor al-fikr, 1997.
Jurakulov. S. (2026). Nuriddin Itrning “Manhaj al-naqd fi ulum al-hadis” asari hadisshunoslikdagi muhim manba (Magistrlik dissertatsiyasi). – Toshkent: O‘zbekiston xalqaro islom akademiyasi.
Kiraz A., Alkasmalhadad A. A Study on The Book of Nureddin 'Itr and Manhaj an-Naqd fī 'ulūm al-Ḥadīth. – Gifad: Gümüşhane Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi, 2023. – 12(23). – S. 312-329.
Kurdian I.R., Pramesta B. va boshq. (2026). The Epistemological Shift in Hadith Science: From al-Hakim’s Systematic Classification to Nur al-Din ‘Itr’s Methodological Framework. – Diroyah: Jurnal Studi Ilmu Hadis, 10(2), 192.
Samohiy M. Al-Manhaj al-hadis fi ulum al-hadis (Mustalah al-hadis qismi va Roviylar qismi). – Qohira : nashriyoti berilmagan, 2000.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
How to Cite
